By Donovan Tan
At first glance, American singer-rapper Donald Glover’s (aka Childish Gambino) “This Is America” and AI artist Danny Bones’ “This Is England” are political artforms that share a critical function: Both aim to deliver acute sociopolitical critique through thoughtful choreography and pointed lyrics. But whereas Glover’s music video boasts critical acclaim as a lucid indictment of racism and gun violence in the United States (US), Danny Bones’ jingoistic anthem for the United Kingdom’s (UK) far right foments ultranationalist and ethno-supremacist sentiment and abets the far right’s rise in the UK and across the wider West. Two questions follow for platforms and P/CVE practitioners: What separates critical art from extremist propaganda? And if depicting hateful ideas is not itself the harm, then what is?
Problems for Moderation
Provocative music videos like Gambino’s and Bones’ complicate moderation with their depictions of violence. Consider the gunshot that ruptures the lively choral opening of “This Is America”. Here, Gambino’s depicted violence stands in for symbolic critique. This presents an interpretation gap that automated moderation, which platforms increasingly rely on, can only partly bridge. Algorithms pick up cues—whether footage looks staged, what audio says—to make ‘educated guesses’ about whether content is transgressive. Moderation has improved markedly since Facebook’s systems failed to flag the 2019 Christchurch livestream: Twitch cut the 2022 Buffalo attack stream within minutes, and platforms now share digital fingerprints (‘hashes’) of known attack footage to facilitate rapid takedown. But these tools match or flag content; they do not interpret it. Editing or distorting a copy can evade both—techniques extremist nasheed (Muslim religious music) producers already exploit. Human reviewers close much of the remaining gap, which is why critical work like Gambino’s still reaches its intended audience.
Bones’ “This Is England” poses a different challenge. The video itself contains no prohibited graphic content. Where violence does appear across his corpus, The Node Project (the influencer collective behind the AI persona) is quick to frame these as artistic expression.
On its surface, Bones’ work belongs to the same genre as “This Is America”: it critiques an ostensibly dysfunctional status quo, using a thinly fictionalised England as its foil. The Node Project’s open use of AI only reinforces this frame. A rapper who does not exist cannot be held to account for what he says, and neither, it seems, can those who write for him. Yet this curated fiction carries real, incendiary political payoffs that resemble those of extremist propaganda. The persona even flirts openly with the label—“I’m far right, far right of all this bullshit divide”—whilst its creators shelter behind plausible deniability. The result is content that is hard to police both practically and normatively.
Bones and The Node Project have been banned repeatedly from Instagram and TikTok. Yet as of October 2026, his catalogue remains freely accessible on YouTube, Facebook, X, Spotify, and Apple Music. Most of us sense something troubling in Bones’ music that is absent from Gambino’s; the question is how to ground that intuition. Žižek’s concept of symbolic violence—applied in limited fashion—offers one.
Naming the Harm: Symbolic Violence
Bones’ corpus extends beyond music videos to bite-sized documentaries on political issues, mockumentaries, autobiographies, and punchier short-form content. Across it, Bones’ persona tidily organises otherwise distinct grievances into a single, total antagonistic worldview. By responding to a panoply of tendentious issues—‘immigration crises’ and ‘invasion’ narratives, censorship, an urgent need to return to religion (and the correct one, at that)—with the same aggrieved, sanctimonious indignation, the persona gives viewers permission to collapse their reflexive, piecemeal outbursts into a singular, coherent rejection of a conspiratorial spectre of a ‘woke left’. The lyrics and choreography of Bones’ music videos externalise and perform the inchoate animus that fuels his audience’s outrage.
This is where Bones departs from Gambino. “This Is America” alerts us to the damaging assumptions we hold without noticing; Bones works to legitimise and entrench them. Consider the scene where Gambino dances with schoolchildren amid violence. As Guthrie Ramsey puts it, the video is about “the fact that we deal with [guns and violence] and consume them as part of entertainment.” The dancing children pull our eyes from the chaos behind them; we are the distracted audience.
As Fast and Pegley gloss it, Žižek’s symbolic violence is “embodied in hegemonic forms of discourse, particularly language,” and “through repetition, it generates power that can then be utilized against agents.” Žižek pairs it with “systemic violence”: “the often catastrophic consequences of the smooth functioning of our economic and political systems.” Symbolic and systemic violence are distinct, but they travel together: discourse that marks some groups as outsiders smooths the way for already fractured systems to treat them as such. Britain’s 2024 anti-immigration riots are a case in point. Bones is rapping about grievances that predate him, but discourse like his infuses them with legitimacy.
In effect, as we uncritically privilege damaging discourses, we become quiet accomplices to arrangements that favour some groups at others’ expense—and legitimise violence, real or rhetorical, against those already marked as outsiders. What audiences do unwittingly, Bones’ creators do by design. This is the truly damaging aspect of extremist propaganda like The Node Project’s: it sanctions violence—both figurative and literal—against the groups it excludes. And there is good reason to take the rancour seriously: real-world extremists already deploy symbolic violence to justify their brutalities, from Christchurch in 2019 to the 2024 UK riots and the 2026 San Diego shootings.
Practical Implications
The author’s own monitoring indicates that The Node Project continues to draw considerable support. It is funded through public donations, internationally sold merchandise, and far-right political backing. For platforms and practitioners, the lesson is that a persona’s frame matters less than what surrounds it: who funds it, where it is staged, and who carries its message offline. In practice, this means evaluating creators and AI personas by their whole corpus, rather than screening individual clips for overtly malicious content.
Donovan Tan is a Research Analyst at the International Centre for Political Violence and Terrorism Research (ICPVTR), a constituent unit of the S. Rajaratnam School of International Studies (RSIS), Nanyang Technological University (NTU). He uses continental philosophy and Lacanian psychoanalysis to inform his research on political violence and extremism. He can be reached at isdonovan.tan@ntu.edu.sg.